A hypothetical seal-reassembly question illustrates the issue. “The O-ring is not broken and its dimensions look almost unchanged. Why does the joint still leak after reassembly?” Geometry is only part of sealing. The joint also needs sufficient contact force throughout service. Compression set and stress relaxation both influence long-term behaviour, but they describe different properties. Measuring the removed ring’s diameter cannot establish its remaining sealing capability.
Two measurements answer different questions
Compression set describes the deformation that remains after a specified compression exposure and recovery procedure. Test temperature, duration, deflection and recovery conditions affect the result. It is a measure of recovery under those conditions.
Compression stress relaxation describes how the reaction force decreases while a specified deformation is maintained. It therefore addresses force retention during compression, rather than simply the shape observed after release.
Compound, temperature, time and liquid exposure influence both properties, but one result does not accurately substitute for the other. A ring that recovers its shape reasonably well may not have maintained adequate force throughout service. Equally, some permanent deformation does not automatically establish leakage in a particular pressurised joint. The actual sealing arrangement remains decisive.
Why similar dimensions can hide different performance
Consider a conceptual example, not measured product data. Two equal-size rings enter equivalent fixtures at the same initial compression and experience the same temperature and liquid. Their recovered shapes may look similar, while a force-retention test under continued compression shows different residual forces.
That possibility does not rank entire rubber families. A specification stating only “NBR, 70 hardness, correct dimensions” may omit compound identity, curing condition and the long-term properties needed for the application. Hardness describes one aspect of the material; it cannot be converted directly into a sealing-life claim.
For purchasing, ask what the reported property actually measures. A percentage without its test method and exposure conditions is insufficient for comparing compounds or suppliers.
Record leakage during cooling as a separate observation
Temperature changes affect elastomer behaviour and the dimensions of plastic or metal mating parts. A joint that seals while operating may reveal insufficient contact force after cooling, a pressure change or housing movement. However, gland dimensions, damaged surfaces, installation twist and chemical compatibility must also be investigated.
Record whether leakage occurred during operation, shutdown, cooling or the next start, together with water temperature, immersion and visible deformation. Identify the leakage interface before dismantling, and retain the ring’s orientation and contact marks. Isolate electrical power and use qualified personnel for any opening of the pump.
Compare suppliers under consistent conditions
| Assessment | Conditions to align | Main question |
|---|---|---|
| Compression set | Specimen, deflection, temperature, duration and recovery procedure | How does the material recover after the specified exposure? |
| Compression stress relaxation | Fixture, deformation, temperature, liquid and force measurement | How much force remains during continued compression? |
| Complete-joint endurance | Actual gland, pressure, thermal cycles and assembly | Does the assembled joint remain sealed? |
A result from hot-air exposure should not be ranked directly against a result from a milder water test. Require batch identification, compound identification and an indication of variation. A supplier’s best individual sample does not necessarily represent routine delivery.
Use component tests to understand the mechanism, then test the complete joint for the intended service. Neither an excellent recovery figure nor a strong initial assembly force removes that need.
Convert the evidence into an appropriate material decision
Define the application and consequences of leakage before selecting the compound and test combination. Continuous warm-water operation, extended idle storage followed by restart, and frequent thermal cycling may require different validation. Do not optimise one compression-set value while overlooking swelling, low-temperature recovery, tearing or installation damage.
Control compound and manufacturing changes after approval. Spare rings also require appropriate packaging and storage. Reusing a removed ring should not depend on whether it still looks round. If returned parts suggest force loss, assess the gland and fastening arrangement as well; a more expensive elastomer may leave the original mismatch unchanged.
Frequently asked questions
Does lower compression set always mean less leakage?
It is useful under comparable conditions, but contact force, joint dimensions, liquid, pressure and assembly also affect leakage. It cannot determine complete-pump performance alone.
Can a thicker ring compensate for stress relaxation?
Do not make that change without validation. A thicker ring changes squeeze, gland fill and assembly loading, potentially causing damage or joint distortion.
Will FKM always retain sealing force longer than NBR?
No. The specific compound, temperature and liquid determine suitability. Compare data under equivalent conditions and confirm the complete joint rather than ranking rubber families universally.
